Can a $140,000 fixer-upper in Philadelphia produce sustainable rental cash flow? The Cash Flow Property Finds video on 1624 Dyre St demonstrates a fast screening process: choose a city within a practical drive, filter for affordable properties, review condition, test rent scenarios, and compare income with expenses.
The video is a useful starting point, but an offer needs a more conservative model. When checked on November 2, 2026, Bright MLS-derived listings showed 1624 Dyre St, Philadelphia, PA 19124 as active at $140,000. The house is not advertised with a tenant, signed lease, verified rent roll, contractor scope, or approved voucher rent.
This is an educational screening—not an appraisal, inspection, financing quote, or promise of returns. Price, status, rent, taxes, insurance, condition, program standards, and financing terms can change.
1624 Dyre St at a glance
| Detail | Current public information | Underwriting treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Asking price | $140,000 | Active MLS-derived price checked November 2, 2026 |
| Property type | Twin / single-family attached home | Confirm legal use, deed, and zoning |
| Bedrooms / bathrooms | 3 / 1 full and 1 half | Listing claim; confirm layout and permits |
| Living area | 1,692 sq. ft. | Public-record and listing figure |
| Lot size | About 2,111 sq. ft. | Verify survey and boundaries |
| Year built | 1945 | Older systems and materials require specialist review |
| Basement | Full, partially finished | Inspect structure, moisture, utilities, and egress |
| Heating / cooling | Gas radiator heat / no central cooling | Verify operation, age, permits, and remaining life |
| 2026 property tax | $2,383 | Listing figure; verify the current tax certificate and post-sale treatment |
| MLS / OPA account | PAPH2681956 / 622036700 | Use both during due diligence |
| Listing condition | Described as needing revitalization | Do not treat as rent-ready |
The current Bright MLS-derived listing describes a large Frankford twin with an open floor plan, dining room, eat-in kitchen, mudroom, half bathroom, backyard, partially finished basement, and three bedrooms. It was listed on October 17, 2026.
The listing and portal data do not agree perfectly. Redfin and Coldwell Banker showed an active $140,000 listing, while Zillow labeled the address off market. Portal delays happen, so confirm current Bright MLS status and seller instructions through an authorized agent before relying on any website.
What the video says—and what still needs proof
The video explains how to search for properties under $150,000 to $200,000 within roughly a two-hour drive. It reviews listing photos, checks advertised rents, looks at a housing-voucher benchmark, and enters scenarios into the Cash Flow Property Finds calculator.
| Video statement or input | Independent check |
|---|---|
| $140,000 purchase price | Matches active MLS-derived listings checked November 2, 2026 |
| 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, 1 half bath, 1,692 sq. ft. | Matches current listing information |
| Mostly paint, flooring, kitchen, or cabinet work | Photos cannot rule out roof, structure, plumbing, electrical, heating, moisture, sewer, or lead work |
| About $10,000–$15,000 of repairs | Not supported by an inspection, written scope, or contractor bids |
| Market rent of roughly $1,600–$2,000 | A range to investigate, not verified rent for this house |
| About $1,730 through Section 8 | The video appears to reference an earlier benchmark; PHA's schedule effective November 1, 2026 is $1,851 gross for a three-bedroom voucher in ZIP 19124 |
| 8.67%–11.58% cap rate | Depends on incomplete expense and renovation assumptions |
| 9.5%–21.65% financed ROI | Cannot be reproduced without exact provider terms, fees, contribution, reserves, and complete expenses |
| $266 monthly cash flow at $1,600 rent | Sensitive to financing terms and omitted operating or capital costs |
| $66 cash flow at the higher rent | The narration appears inconsistent with the displayed comparison; do not rely on either number without rebuilding the model |
The repair estimate is the largest unresolved input. The listing invites a buyer to “revitalize” the home, and the video itself calls it a fixer-upper. Cosmetic photos cannot establish the condition of concealed systems. Treat $10,000–$15,000 as a hypothesis until a licensed inspector and contractors produce a written scope.
What current rent evidence supports
The sale listing does not identify an existing tenant, lease, deposit, or rent history. Every rent in this article is a prospective scenario, not current income.
Zillow's automated Rent Zestimate was $1,651 per month when reviewed, but an automated estimate is not a leased comparable. The video reports a broad Rent.com range of approximately $1,600–$2,000 for three-bedroom properties in the area. Those advertisements may differ in condition, size, block, utilities, amenities, and concessions.
The Philadelphia Housing Authority payment-standard schedule effective November 1, 2026 places ZIP 19124 in Group 1, Basic Rents. Its three-bedroom payment standard is $1,851 per month.
That $1,851 figure is gross rent, meaning contract rent plus the applicable utility allowance. It is not a guaranteed payment to the owner. PHA uses the lower of voucher size or unit bedroom size, reviews rent reasonableness, accounts for tenant-paid utilities, requires the unit and tenancy to qualify, and may approve a different contract rent.
For a first-pass screen, this article tests:
- $1,650: close to the current automated rent estimate.
- $1,851: the current three-bedroom PHA gross payment standard for ZIP 19124, used only as a benchmark.
- $2,000: an upside scenario from the video's advertised-rent research that needs strong leased-comparable support.
Conservative cash-purchase screen
The base model uses a $30,000 renovation and compliance placeholder, not the video's $10,000–$15,000 visual estimate. This is not a contractor quote; it is a screening allowance until inspection results and bids are available.
| Cash-basis component | Modeled amount |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | $140,000 |
| Closing and acquisition allowance | $7,000 |
| Renovation / compliance placeholder | $30,000 |
| Illustrative all-cash basis | $177,000 |
The operating screen assumes:
| Modeled expense | Assumption |
|---|---|
| Vacancy allowance | 10% of scheduled rent |
| Professional management | 8% of scheduled rent |
| Routine maintenance | 5% of scheduled rent |
| Capital-replacement reserve | 5% of scheduled rent |
| Property tax | $2,383 per year |
| Landlord insurance placeholder | $1,800 per year |
| Owner-paid utilities | $0 in model; verify water, sewer, and lease responsibility |
The four percentage allowances total 28% of scheduled rent. The model excludes financing payments, leasing commissions, income taxes, legal and accounting costs, licensing, lead work, construction carrying costs, extraordinary repairs, and any owner-paid utilities.
Recalculated rent scenarios
| Monthly rent scenario | Annual gross rent | Vacancy, management, maintenance and capital allowances | Tax and insurance | Annual modeled amount before financing | Monthly equivalent | Yield on $177,000 basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $1,650 | $19,800 | $5,544 | $4,183 | $10,073 | $839 | 5.69% |
| $1,851 | $22,212 | $6,219 | $4,183 | $11,810 | $984 | 6.67% |
| $2,000 | $24,000 | $6,720 | $4,183 | $13,097 | $1,091 | 7.40% |
These are screening results, not guaranteed net operating income or spendable cash flow. The middle row does not mean PHA will approve $1,851 as contract rent. It tests the current gross payment standard only after deducting the same operating allowances used in the other rows.
The $1,650 scenario produces about $839 per month before financing and excluded costs. That is materially different from calling the property a 9.5% financed return because this table includes management, capital reserves, a larger repair basis, and no unverified financing structure.
Replace every placeholder with documented inputs in the Cash Flow Property Finds calculator.
Repair cost can change the decision
Holding the middle $1,851 scenario and its $11,810 annual modeled amount constant shows how the renovation budget changes the preliminary cash yield:
| Renovation placeholder | Estimated cash basis | Preliminary yield before financing |
|---|---|---|
| $15,000 | $162,000 | 7.29% |
| $30,000 | $177,000 | 6.67% |
| $50,000 | $197,000 | 5.99% |
The $15,000 row does not claim the work can be completed for that amount. The purpose is to show why an inspection, code search, lead assessment, and trade-by-trade bids should come before a final offer.
Philadelphia compliance belongs in the budget
Philadelphia's official long-term rental guidance requires landlords to address zoning and legal occupancy, obtain the appropriate activity and Rental Licenses, remain tax and code compliant, and provide a Certificate of Rental Suitability to a new tenant.
Because the house was built in 1945, Philadelphia's lead rules are especially important. A pre-1978 rental generally must be certified lead-safe or lead-free for a new or renewed lease and for a Rental License. Price testing, correction, certified work, documentation, and possible delays separately from cosmetic renovation.
Also check open permits, violations, utility balances, rental-license history, and whether the half bathroom and finished basement work are legally documented. A prior owner's license does not automatically eliminate a new owner's application requirements.
Cash or certified halal financing
An all-cash model shows the property's operating performance without leverage. A cash buyer still needs closing funds, renovation money, construction carrying costs, lease-up expenses, and reserves.
Anyone considering certified halal or Sharia-compliant financing should obtain a complete written proposal from a qualified provider and review it with appropriate legal, tax, and Sharia advisers. Enter the actual acquisition cost, initial contribution, payment schedule, profit or rent component, fees, ownership terms, insurance obligations, reserves, and any final purchase or balloon provision.
The video's financed returns cannot be independently validated from a generic monthly payment. A financing label does not reduce repair, vacancy, rent, title, tax, insurance, or compliance risk.
Due diligence before an offer
- 1Confirm live MLS status. Verify the $140,000 price, showing access, seller disclosures, offer instructions, and any status change since November 2, 2026.
- 2Inspect the full property. Include roof, twin wall, masonry, foundation, basement moisture, drainage, sewer lateral, plumbing, electrical service, radiator system, windows, and fire safety.
- 3Build a written renovation scope. Obtain licensed trade bids with permits, materials, labor, cleanup, contingency, and completion time.
- 4Review permits and code history. Confirm legal use, bathroom layout, basement work, open permits, violations, and zoning through Philadelphia records.
- 5Price lead compliance. Determine the required testing, certification, safe work practices, and correction budget before lease-up.
- 6Verify rent with leased comparables. Ask at least two local property managers for recent leases on similar renovated three-bedroom twins in the immediate area.
- 7Verify voucher economics directly. Confirm the applicable voucher size, utility allowance, inspection standards, rent-reasonableness process, landlord paperwork, and likely timing with PHA.
- 8Order tax, title, utility, and insurance checks. Confirm taxes without an owner-occupant exemption, liens, water balances, deed history, and a property-specific landlord quote.
- 9Stress-test the budget. Model lower rent, longer vacancy, higher repairs, construction delays, leasing costs, and a major replacement.
- 10Compare capital structures. Compare cash with certified halal financing only after rent, repairs, reserves, and the provider's complete written terms are documented.
For another Philadelphia case study with an existing-rent claim, read the 36 S Cecil St rental analysis.
Verdict: worth investigating, not yet proven
At $140,000, 1624 Dyre St fits the affordable-property search strategy and may deserve further investigation by an investor prepared to renovate an older Philadelphia twin. The 1,692-square-foot layout and three bedrooms create rental potential, but the listing language and video photos point to meaningful condition risk.
The $1,650 scenario is the most defensible starting point from current public evidence. The $1,851 PHA figure is a gross program benchmark—not guaranteed rent—and $2,000 needs strong leased comparables after renovation. With a $30,000 renovation placeholder, the conservative screen produces a 5.69% to 7.40% pre-financing yield across the tested rents.
The property should not be purchased on the assumption that repairs will stop at $15,000 or that a voucher automatically creates the advertised income. The deal becomes decision-ready only after condition, compliance, rent, taxes, insurance, and financing are documented.
Frequently asked questions
Is 1624 Dyre St currently listed for $140,000?
Bright MLS-derived listings showed the property active at $140,000 when checked November 2, 2026. Zillow showed it off market, illustrating why buyers should confirm current MLS status before acting.
Is the property already rented?
The sale listings reviewed did not show a tenant, lease, rent roll, or security deposit. Every rent used here is a prospective scenario.
Will PHA guarantee $1,851 per month?
No. $1,851 is the current gross three-bedroom payment standard for Group 1 ZIP codes including 19124. Voucher size, utility allowances, inspection, eligibility, rent reasonableness, the lease, and PHA approval determine the actual contract and subsidy amounts.
Can the renovation be completed for $10,000–$15,000?
That has not been verified. The figure came from a visual review. Obtain a full inspection, code and permit records, lead assessment, and written contractor bids.
Does the analysis include a mortgage or halal financing payment?
No. The tables show an all-cash operating screen before financing. A buyer considering certified halal or Sharia-compliant financing should model the provider's complete written terms separately.
Source video: Philadelphia Rental Property for $140K — Will It Cash Flow? | 1624 Dyre St
This article is educational, not financial, legal, tax, construction, insurance, housing-program, or Sharia advice. Listing status, rent estimates, program standards, taxes, insurance, rules, and property condition are time-sensitive and were checked on November 2, 2026.
Analyze Your Next Deal in Seconds
Calculate Cash-on-Cash ROI, Cap Rates, Multi-Unit Rents, and 5-Year Equity Growth with automated Zillow import.
